The Lost Kitchen
About
American (New), Salad, Soup
Price Range : $31-60 ($$$)
Location
Adress: 22 Mill St, Freedom, ME 04941
Phone: (207) 382-3333
Work Hours
Business info
- list_altTakes ReservationsYes
- directions_carDeliveryNo
- move_to_inboxTake-outNo
- credit_cardAccepts Credit CardsYes
- local_parkingParkingPrivate Lot
- directions_bikeBike ParkingYes
- accessibilityGood for KidsNo
- groupGood for GroupsYes
- insert_emoticonAmbienceIntimate, Romantic, Classy
- volume_upNoise LevelAverage
- local_barAlcoholBeer & Wine Only
- transit_enterexitOutdoor SeatingYes
- wifiWi-FiFree
- tvHas TVYes
- turned_in_notWaiter ServiceYes
- fastfoodCatersYes
Reviews
-
Richard L.
There is so much that I'd love to say about the Lost Kitchen (TLK), but these simple words on a computer cannot do justice to the four-plus hours we spent in the middle of nowhere, Freedom, ME. I've had a couple weeks to dwell over each and every detail of the night, and as much as delving into the intricacies of each part of the seven (plus)-course meal would be a great way for me to reminiscence about the good times we had, it simply isn't the way to go for a review of TLK. Not only will each night's menu be a little different depending on the ingredients available that day, but the element of surprise when you first show up in front of TLK with the freshly printed menu laid out on the wooden table is just part of the experience that I cannot justifiably take away from you. Part of allure of TLK is the simplicity of the night - the only choice you make is what you'll pair your evenings indulgences with as far as choice beverages. Otherwise, leave it to the genius kitchen of Erin French, sit back, and enjoy. Simply put, TLK is a dining experience of a lifetime, but even more than that, it was a night full of good company, warm conversations, humbling and inspiring stories, and a momentary respite from all this world has to offer.
Set aside all the hype and hubbub of TLK that has been generated over the last couple years from various newspapers (ahem Washington Post) and others. Without all of that, Erin French at the helm of TLK humbly stands at the precipice of the best that Maine (and might I say the USA) has to offer from a culinary experience. Where else can you find a mill, seated to its 40-person capacity, full of strangers and yet a sense of commonality and connection throughout - connected by the pursuit of a rare opportunity to be served by the Lost Kitchen's all-female staff as well as Ms. French herself. This is no Handmaid's Tale knock against TLK, but rather the inspirational part of TLK's story.
TLK is more than just a restaurant with hard-to-get reservations; it is a testament to Erin French's grit and perseverance, a testament to TLK's support of the local Freedom, ME community, and a testament to fact that Erin and her staff all do this out of their love for what they are doing.
In an instant, TLK's business could easily double in size and revenues through the roof. But alas, TLK was never built to be that. What makes TLK special is the personal touches that Erin and her staff give. Where else have I gone where every staff knew me by name and were excited to finally meet the person that I drew on my 3x5 card? Nowhere.
Thank you to TLK, to Erin, to Meg, to Maia, and the rest of the lovely staff that made this night one for the ages. Until next time... -
Brett F.
My new favorite overall Maine dining experience. I can't think of a better dinner anywhere, actually. And I entered skeptical. Mailing in a postcard to possibly get a reservation? A lofty $135 price-fixe menu? A wine cellar? It all sounds so pretentious. And maybe it is, but it's amazing, and this should be first on your list for next season.
The Lost Kitchen is an hour and a half from Portland in essentially the middle of nowhere. When you finally arrive, the magic begins. You're ushered into a wine cellar to choose your beverages for the evening. It's no longer BYOB, but the prices are fair, with wine ranging from low $20's to probably infinity. The cellar is also open all evening, for if (when) you need more.
The actual restaurant, in a restored mill, is breathtaking. The attention to detail is so precise that this could be a set at Disney World. With the ambient waterfall as your backdrop, I feel confident this is the single best dining room in the state (at least without an ocean view).
Since you select your own drinks in advance, pre pay for dinner on the phone, and have no menu choices, the service is...different. The myriad of black-clad servers perform a ballet of presenting and clearing dishes. They're more stage hands in a classic play than active participants, and interaction is limited. Compared to traditional fine dining, it could be viewed as cold. I found it efficient. The owner, Erin, is the lead, producing and explaining most courses herself. She was charming and engaging, especially during the toast to the room.
The food:
-A trio of cheeses and house made butters, olives, bone marrow spread, salami and crostini: 8/10 stars. A great start.
-Oysters on the half shell (two oysters each): 10/10. Best oysters I've ever had, with extra points for presentation.
-Mini Crab Roll: 10/10, and the surprise highlight of my evening. By far the best crab roll of my life. Luke's Lobster should feel ashamed.
-Sorbet palate cleaner: 10/10. Just a bite, but in such a cute duck bowl that you'll want to steal (please don't).
-Soup of spring alliums, smoked ricotta, fried chive blossom and arugula: 9/10. Served table side, with the fried blossom as the highlight.
-Baby romaine salad: 7/10. The weakest dish for me. Incredibly fresh, but not a standout.
-Organic Maine tenderloin, wild ramp butter, creamy polenta, asparagus & olives, fava leaves & blossoms: 9/10. Supposedly the infrequent tenderloin night is extra special. Cooked perfectly medium rare, a knife was unnecessary. I just wish we had more of it, especially with the skimpy polenta serving.
-Rhubarb Spoon Cake: 9/10. A massive individual serving and the ideal finale to the evening.
-House made cookies: 9/10. You won't be hungry by this point, but why not indulge?
The Lost Kitchen is a $200+ per person restaurant, all in. But it's easily worth it, and is a unique Maine experience that everyone should try. Just make your postcard creative to better your odds in the "random" drawing. -
Alex G.
Simply wow. From start to finish, this is a dining experience like no other. Without spoiling all the fun, suffice it to say that it's a terrific once in a lifetime experience. Owner/Chef Erin French is an amazing woman who connects with each guest on a personal level, and brings a huge breath of fresh air to the highest levels of the culinary world. She and her (all-woman) team took phenomenal care of us throughout the evening (almost four hours). The food was creative, polished, and often whimsical, yet never snobby or highbrow. Yes, it's a hike to get to Freedom, Maine, but for the lucky few it's a night to remember.
-
Andre M.
Restaurant is run by elitist snobs. Nearly
Impossible to get in and they discriminate against people from outside of Maine unfortunately. While food is good, reservation process and the lack of transparency and equity is a real shame. I cannot recommend. -
kirk m.
As a chef I come into a place ... sometimes looking for flaws. This place has none. Service, food , service again. Soup to nuts I could find none. The servers were fantastic. I wanted to break through the hype.... I cant. I cant. What a place. So well managed. So well run. Food ...perfect. wish I could come every week